Saint Anselm



Proslogion

In Behalf of the Fool
Chapter 3




Table of Contents

Catalogue of Titles




Logos Virtual Library



Catalogue

Saint Anselm (1033-1109)

Proslogion

Translated by Sidney Norton Deane

In Behalf of the Fool

An answer to the argument of Anselm in the Proslogion
by Gaunilon, a monk of Marmoutier

Chapter 3


Hence, your example of the painter who already has in his understanding what he is to paint cannot agree with this argument. For the picture, before it is made, is contained in the artificer’s art itself; and any such thing, existing in the art of an artificer, is nothing but a part of his understanding itself. A joiner, St. Augustine says, when he is about to make a box in fact, first has it in his art. The box which is made in fact is not life; but the box which exists in his art is life. For the artificer’s soul lives, in which all these things are, before they are produced. Why, then, are these things life in the living soul of the artificer, unless because they are nothing else than the knowledge or understanding of the soul itself?

With the exception, however, of those facts which are known to pertain to the mental nature, whatever, on being heard and thought out by the understanding, is perceived to be real, undoubtedly that real object is one thing, and the understanding itself, by which the object is grasped, is another. Hence, even if it were true that there is a being than which a greater is inconceivable: yet to this being, when heard of and understood, the not yet created picture in the mind of the painter is not analogous.





In Behalf of the Fool
Chapter 2


In Behalf of the Fool
Chapter 4